Solving a bunch of problems with one test

MPI should be doing mandatory retesting of the entire population every 10 years.

This solves a bunch of problems with one fell stroke. I recently filled out a survey for MPI where I gave them my opinion on the matter:

Starting as soon as possible, we could ease into this new strategy by rolling it out on a small scale through a lottery.

100x drivers' names should be drawn from a lottery to be subjected to a written test this year.

Those who fail should be forced to redo their driving test.

Those who fail have their licence suspended and are mandated X hours of driving instruction with a qualified instructor.

The next year, same thing (having removed the names who were subjected to testing): 100x drivers up for re-testing.

This lottery strategy should continue as capacity is built into the driver testing system to allow for the entire population (not merely a draw) to be subjected to this mandatory resting rubric on a 10-year cycle.

Or maybe once the entire population is being re-tested with the written component, the lottery is maintained to select individuals for random driving tests (even for those who passed the written component.)

Why?

Driver behaviour is atrocious: some of it is lack of cognitive facility that is not caught (or is called ageism if it's pointed out) while some of it is simple lack of skill, inattention and forgetfulness of the rules.

We will ALL benefit if we're all *forced* to brush up on the rules.

So besides solving the problem of getting inept seniors off the road without accusations of ageism, it also solves the problem of simply bad drivers. Additionally it addresses the "need for education" issue that frequently comes up.

It will makes it more viable to introduce new roadway features (or to make amendments to the highway traffic act) because folks will have opportunity to *learn* in their studying to re-pass their written driver's test.

Voluntary "re-education" through advertising campaigns will only ever do so much. Highly incentivized "re-education due to the threat of failing a test" will be much more effective.

Comments

Winnipeg Transit woes

“We’ve increased support for municipalities year after year because we know strong communities depend on reliable, stable and predictable funding increases,” Municipal and Northern Relations Minister Glen Simard said in an emailed statement to the Free Press Tuesday. https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/breakingnews/2026/06/23/winnipeg-transit-needs-funding-boost-additional-staff-to-follow-new-provincial-accessibility-regulations-city-report This in answer to City of Winnipeg chair of Public Works Janice Lukes plea for the province to cough up money for the needed upgrades. Listen carefully because these are words I won't often say: I gotta agree with Lukes on this one. If the province is handing down new standards, given their higher capacity for raising revenues, they ought to help the city fund meeting said standards. What Simard fails to acknowledge is that those "year after year" funding increases started at the bottom basement after Conservative cuts and likely h...

more journalistic malpractice from Canada's national broadcaster

The government has just rammed through legislation to turn Canada into a police surveillance state where all the democratic and processed based guard-rails have been removed. They used some legislative loophole to force a vote on amendments without debate at a committee meeting at midnight. But this is what the front page of our national broadcaster's news site looks like. Do you see any mention of Bill C-22? Do you see any word of a midnight SECU session with a forced vote? Do you see any mention of MPs in tears at how democracy is being shredded before their very eyes? Do you see anything removing about all legal protections against having your data intercepted, read and kept on file (in a word of hackers and data breaches)? Do you see anything about how experts in Australia (who have already gone partway down the path Canada has just widened, flatted, and turned into a racetrack) are warning Canadians not to do this? No. The CBC is spineless. Just a mouthpiece for whoever wield...

Carney's sound check

The Liberals are advertising a summer survey. Let me Mr Carney know what you think! Of course, the multiple choice questions force you to give the answers Carney wants to hear, but fortunately, there's an open box for further comment at the end with a 2500 character limit. I don't have all day to spend on this so it's a slightly in coherent rant, but I can't let this man think everything is fine while he turns this country into a totalitarian surveillance police state whose only industry is war-making. https://action.liberal.ca/a-summer-sound-check/ Here's what I think, Mr Carney. The things that "stand out" the most for me are the things that horrify the most. Every single thing Carney has done or championed since April 2025 is awful for ordinary Canadians (only good for Carney's investment portfolio). You can shove your AI. Yes, Canadians need protection from AI but your disgraced grifter of a "AI minister" is the last person to do that...

kar0ling

Read more posts by subject (label)

Search This Blog