Skip to main content

Fines without teeth

The heat is on: no more frozen bus rides, province vows

The heat is on: no more frozen rides

From the FreeP: 

"After years of headlines about frigid rides to and from Winnipeg, heat on commercial buses will be mandatory this winter, the province announced Monday."

"Bus operators must examine their heat systems daily and provincial bus inspectors will conduct random stops. They will have the authority to place any vehicle that doesn’t comply out of service."

I've never sat on an unheated bus from Thompson, so maybe I'm wrong and it is in fact better to have no ride than a cold ride.

Just threatening operators with random inspectors and grounded buses seems like punishing the passengers, though. How about just going straight to the fine (maybe don't bench the bus unless the bus company is a repeat offender?) and making it hurt: $10,000.

"If a company is caught disobeying rules, it will be fined either $174, $298 or a combined total of $472, depending on the case."

“The fines haven’t been reviewed for some time,” Naylor said, asked if the charges were severe enough. “We are open to reviewing the fines.”

This "ground the bus" rule punishes the bus companies in the kind of way that incentivizes them not change, risk fines, and if worse comes to worst, just shut down (since they have to pay to fix a bus plus lose passenger revenue for the time the bus is out of service getting fixed). 

Either way, passengers are stuck.

Instead, give violators a fine that says "we are icily serious about this". A fine that says "it will be cheaper for you to fix your buses now rather threatening passengers lives while you play chicken with inspectors."

Sigh. Why are Manitoba institutions so averse to fines that actually make a point? 

Well, they are happy to ding just-trying-their-best homeowners with massive fines for firefighting costs should a being-worked-on house catch fire. Likely as not the reason the house is considered vacant is that the owner is stalled on their renovations, waiting for a city inspector to come and give them a permit to proceed. 

But folks who intentionally undertake reckless behaviour to cause harm -- bus company operators who knowingly run buses without heat for hours-long trips in well-below freezing weather, motorists who exceed posted speedlimits by measures of 10s not 1s -- these folks get slap-on-the wrist fines. Less than $500 for having risked 20-40 people's live to hypothermia. Only a few hundred (decidedly less than annual insurance costs) for wanton and reckless speeding.

Government interference on personal liberties may not be something we should take lightly or welcome without critical thinking, but failing to use government powers to restrict/punish/reduce severely antisocial behaviour that clearly endangers innocent bystander's safety is just irresponsible. Risking others' lives for your own jollies or to pad your pocketbook isn't a valid exercise of personal freedom.

Labels:

Comments

kar0ling said…
Or the reverse: punishing seniors community clubs with astronomic fee increases. So short-sighted to cut community centre funding!
https://www.winnipegfreepress.com/breakingnews/2024/09/26/seniors-fear-rec-programs-in-jeopardy-by-escalating-facility-fees
October 21, 2024 at 11:26 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Money

The high incidence of money talk here is surprising to me, given the scarcity of either hard cash or savings accounts. Not that no one has money here, but living a basically subsistence existence off a jungle farm with only one major crash crop a year means you never have a whole lot of cash -- either on paper or in hand. We're currently entering the season of money here in Bekondo, when the cocoa crop is mostly harvested, dried and sold to buyers. Christmas is party time, not because of Christ but because of cash. It's a lively time for parties, running a generator to power lights and music, trucking in drinks to flow with goodwill. It's the time when schools put their foot down and demand tuition fees be paid or students leave. It's a time of increased crime because people are travelling to visit family and money is around. Taxis double and triple in price -- because they can -- until December 25th, after which the frenzy abruptly stops and prices return to normal (so...
Post a Comment
Read more

The anti-bike blog

OR I do not think [that word] means what you think it means It has become a weekly, almost daily occurrence. A how-to article or blog post will come across my path – usually in my facebook feed – touting the wonders of winter cycling. Not one to learn a lesson quickly, I keep clicking on them. Inevitably, I navigate away in frustration. It’s fun! It’s easy! Anyone can do it! You don’t need special gear; you can even look chic while you’re doing it. Oh, and get off your high horse – being a winter cyclist doesn’t make you special. This is the message of all these articles. Lies, I tell you. Now, far be it from me to dissuade people from cycling, but I think we may need different words for the varying circumstances that fall under the umbrella term “winter cycling.” Take Vancouver and Seattle, for example, where bicycle enthusiasts will talk about “winter” cycling. I’ll grant you that a bone-chilling, relentless, drenching rain is its own special brand of miserable to bi...
4 comments
Read more

Infidel again

I just finished reading Infidel and I have to say I greatly respect this woman. What a story. And what a character, to have endured it all and emerged a determined, principled, passionate but not bitter or unyielding woman. A quote from her book: People are always asking me what it's like to live with death threats. It's like being diagnosed with a chronic disease. It may flare up and kill you, but it may not. It could happen in a week, or not for decades. The people who ask me this have usually grown up in rich countries, Western Europe and [North] America, after the Second World War. They take life for granted. Where I grew up, death is a constant visitor. Which reminds me -- on a related topic, one of the things that bothers me about Islam is how often its followers' reactions to offences are so disproportionate. A Western journalist composes editorial cartoons satirizing the Prophet Mohammad; violence erupts in the Middle East, including attacks on the Danish and Norwe...
2 comments
Read more