Skip to main content

Bubble zone discussion side-tracked by bias

 

Dear Free Press

Re: “Bubble zones sought after protests clash over Hamas” AKA “Pro-Palestinian protest at Jewish campus sparks call for safety-zone legislation”

Thank you for changing the headline of Chris Kitching’s article on the event by Students Supporting Israel at the Asper Community Campus.

The body of the article raises good questions about the appropriateness of protesting religious spaces.

However, even after the removal of the gross mischaracterization from the headline, the second paragraph of the article gratuitously invokes Hamas, biasing the discussion.

Why does the article prominently invoke memory of the violent and cruel attack on October 7, 2023, without any mention of the more salient point that the event that raised the discussion platformed soldiers of the army that has been committing a genocide for more than 500 days?

(The Rome Statute, of which Canada is a signatory, defines war crimes and genocide and other states’ obligations not to participate in or supporter perpetrators. The International Court of Justice has more than a year ago ruled it is plausible that the state of Israel is guilty of genocide. Yet the slaughter and destruction has not only continued but intensified.)

We should have discussions about protecting the privilege of religious persons to practice their faith traditions unharassed. But in so doing, we must acknowledge that when religiously-designated spaces function like community centres, hosting all kinds of events with other emphases, including overtly political and ideological matters, clear principles for protecting religious zones become harder to discern.

But it’s especially difficult to come to fair conclusions if discussions start with inflammatory conversation stoppers and unmentioned facts.

**The FreeP only wants to publish letters that are original, so I’m holding off publishing this for a while until I’m sure they won’t use it.

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

It's a girl!

I awoke this morning to the sound of my phone ringing. It wasn't the first time the bells and whistles had attempted to pull me from my slumber so I knew it meant one of two things: either I'd overslept and my boss was calling to find out where I was, or the much anticipated baby had announced her intention to make an entrance. Felicitously, it was the latter. After a lightning fast labour lasting a mere 2 hours, Mai-Anh Esther made her entry into the world at 8:35 am (the preferred interval for Braun babies. Jon, Rebecca, and I were all born between 8 and 8:30 in the morning while Lien was born around 8 in the evening.) She is a hearty 9 lbs 2 oz and 20 1/2 inches long. "She's already got more hair than Lien does!" was the first comment made by both Jon and me. She's a perfectly contented, sleepy little girl who's hardly opened her eyes once, even to let mommy see them, and she had no objection to being passed from person to person all evening, nor to Li...
3 comments
Read more

entering the blog world

I've finally given in to the lure of blogging. Actually, if it weren't for Cameroon, I probably wouldn't be doing this; my excuse for succumbing to the pull of popular culture is that a blog is a very pragmatic way to keep in touch with people at home while I'm gone. Thus the title -- the focus is on my journey to and experience in Cameroon. So you likely shan't see much here till things heat up a bit more.
2 comments
Read more

Flights

I've got tickets! In faith that all the money will come together, my tickets have been purchased. So now I have to go! There was a significantly cheaper flight option with Air Maroc that involved an overnight in Paris and in Casablanca, but I opted for the same Air France flight from Paris to Douala that Dan and Lisa will be on. Frankly, I'm somewhat relieved the latter option was available. Obviously, I must have some sense of adventure to be willing to spend 10 months in Cameroon--and I do--but it's not quite up to the former challenge just yet. I'll likely be quite wound up as it is--the last thing I'll need in my state of excitement and fretful anticipation is to spend three days alone trying to reach my destination, getting no sleep, dealing with unfamiliar languages, and arriving alone to spend a half-day cartrip down roads in less than perfect condition with a local stranger. Now I'm not saying I'm unwilling to be challenged or that any one of these ...
5 comments
Read more